VFX Voice

The award-winning definitive authority on all things visual effects in the world of film, TV, gaming, virtual reality, commercials, theme parks, and other new media.

Winner of two prestigious 2018 Folio Awards for excellence in publishing.

Subscribe now to the VFX Voice Quarterly Print Edition.

SUBSCRIPTION & SINGLE ISSUES

Full Access to VFXVoice.com website is available FREE for a limited time only. Exclusive web content will soon be available only to VFXVoice subscribers and VES members.


April 03
2018

ISSUE

Spring 2018

Double Negative: Double Decades of Double Positives

By IAN FAILES

A shot is set up during the filming of Pitch Black. In its first film outing, DNEG collaborated closely with practical effects vendor John Cox’s Creature Workshop in delivering alien CG creatures. (Image courtesy of John Cox’s Creature Workshop)

Gringott’s Dragon from Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, a DNEG creation. By the time of this final film, the VFX studio had become one of the major vendors for the franchise. (Image copyright © 2010 Warner Bros. Pictures. All rights reserved.)

Not too many studios can boast two decades of existence in the sometimes volatile visual effects industry. But Double Negative, founded in 1998, reaches that milestone this year, having grown from a 30-person startup to a global studio with thousands of employees.

Ultimately, DNEG has emerged as one of the powerhouse visual effects studios in feature filmmaking. It is known for anchoring major releases, as well as continuing to work on a range of lower budget films, and has now branched out into television and animated features. In the process, the studio’s work has been honored by three Academy Awards (for Inception, Interstellar and Ex Machina).

For its 20th anniversary, VFX Voice spoke to some of DNEG’s key staff for a look back at the rise of the visual effects studio.

The folding Parisian landscape as seen in Inception wowed audiences and was one of many startling, yet invisible visual effects incorporated into Christopher Nolan’s film. (Image copyright © 2010 Warner Bros. Pictures. All rights reserved.)

TWO DECADES OF DNEG

While it is now a massive visual effects studio, DNEG started small. It was formed largely by a group of artists who had been working together at The Moving Picture Company in London for several years. Polygram backed the group to start their own outfit, with the first project the Vin Diesel sci-fi film Pitch Black.

Pitch Black would prove to be a significant challenge for the newly formed DNEG team (who did not even have a name when they started on the film – they actually referred to themselves as ‘Newco’, as in ‘new company’, for the first few months). The studio was without a permanent base in London and was yet to purchase much-needed workstations. Also, Pitch Black was filming in Queensland, Australia, the other side of the world.

“Of course,” relates DNEG Co-founder and Visual Effects Supervisor Paul Franklin, “once we got there we had all sorts of technical problems getting our first SGI workstations set up, made all the worse by the fact that our tech team was 10,000 miles away. The Internet wasn’t up to much back then – remember ISDN lines running at a blistering 28Kbps? – so communication with the home base was pretty difficult.”

Franklin suggests that “much of the ‘core DNA’ of Double Negative was laid down on Pitch Black, which was VFX supervised by Co-founder Peter Chiang, and still remains to this day. Very quickly, in fact, the studio began forming key relationships with filmmakers, producers and film studios. DNEG was also well-placed to benefit from a dramatic rise in film and VFX production occurring in the UK, especially with the advent of the Harry Potter films.

Ex Machina was recognized with a Best Visual Effects Oscar®, perhaps surprising many after being up against a host of much larger effects films. (Image copyright © 2012 A24. All rights reserved.)
Among DNEG’s several contributions to Blade Runner 2049 was the large hologram version of the character Joi. (Image copyright © 2017 Warner Bros. Pictures.All rights reserved.)

RISE OF UK VFX; RISE OF DNEG

As film production in the UK ramped up, so too did competition among visual effects studios, many of which happened to be located in the Soho area of London. DNEG Co-founder Alex Hope says the focus in those earlier years was to not only help grow DNEG as a business and as a creative enterprise, but also the local industry as a whole.

Although it did not achieve wide success, John Carter proved to be a major demonstration of DNEG’s animated creatures pipeline. (Image copyright © 2012 Walt Disney Pictures. All rights reserved.)

“One of our primary aims was to get the visual effects industry in the UK on the map,” recalls Hope. “Through that period, the Harry Potter films started being made, and we first became involved on Prisoner of Azkaban, released in 2004. Those films, and the commitment of Warner Bros., David Heyman [producer of Harry Potter films] and everyone associated with those films to want them to be done in the UK gave confidence to British visual effects companies, and gave confidence to Double Negative – that we could invest in training and R&D and capital expenditure and build our business.”

Another cornerstone relationship that DNEG cultivated was with Christopher Nolan, first working with the director on Batman Begins and then several others (see sidebar). DNEG also quickly became one of the major contributors to other large franchises such as The Hunger Games series, Bond films, the DC Extended Universe and the Marvel Cinematic Universe. For that to happen, DNEG had to grow – quickly and creatively – not only in London but around the world.

The studio now has locations in London, Vancouver, Mumbai, Los Angeles, Chennai and Montréal (DNEG had an office in Singapore but closed it in 2016). Another event also had the effect of expanding the studio: its merger with Prime Focus World in 2014. This global expansion certainly reflects the state of the industry – many other studios have set up in multiple countries, attracted by lower costs of production, tax credits, incentives and the availability of a near 24-hour production schedule.

DNEG’s Oscar® winners, in foreground (from left): Paul Franklin, Paul Norris, Andrew Whitehurst, Mark Ardington, Andrew Lockley and Pete Bebb, joined by Alex Hope and Matt Holben.

DNEG’S CONSISTENT CREW

For a studio in operation for 20 years, a surprising number of crew who were there at the beginning or in the earliest days of production are still at the studio, and have risen to become experienced supervisors, producers and part of management. Visual Effects Supervisor Pete Bebb, for example, was DNEG’s first runner, and later won an Oscar for Inception. Many other experienced supervisors started their careers at the studio. Co-founder Matt Holben says DNEG is firm on the importance of investing in staff: “Anybody can get investment and go and buy infrastructure and machinery and whatever, but what makes a company magic is the group of people that you have working with you – your team, who you surround yourself with.”

That’s a view echoed by Peter Chiang, who has been at DNEG from the very beginning and marvels at the level of talent fostered at the studio and coming in from around the world. “We encourage individuals to pursue their goals and take on new challenges, all with a guiding hand from a team of very experienced individuals. We understand new talent may want to flex their wings and move on and try other companies, but while they are at DNEG we want to them to enjoy their experience and get the most out of working on the projects.”

DNEG Chief Scientist Oliver James (center), holding the BAFTA, with the Interstellar R&D team and collaborator Professor Kip Thorne, holding the Oscar®.

“Supervising is just as enjoyable for me today as it was back then. The projects are bigger and so we have grown the company, and the result is that we can do more creative things because we have fantastic, talented crew that work hard and know what they are doing. The company has invested in a more flexible pipeline that links the whole company to maximize this creative process allowing everyone to contribute in creating great shots.”

—Peter Chiang, Co-Founder, Double Negative

NEW HORIZONS

DNEG is still primarily known for feature film visual effects. Its major recent projects include Dunkirk, Blade Runner 2049, Wonder Woman, Baby Driver, Pacific Rim Uprising and Annihilation. Plus, there’s a slew of films to come, including Avengers: Infinity War, Ant-Man and the Wasp, Deadpool 2, First Man, M:I 6 – Mission Impossible, Bohemian Rhapsody, Godzilla: King of Monsters, Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, The Kid Who Would Be King and Venom.

Like many other VFX companies, DNEG has also branched out into new areas. These include animated features – via a partnership with Locksmith Animation –and television. DNEG TV, in particular, has been one of the busiest new parts of the studio after launching only in 2013. The outfit boasts credits on shows such as Altered Carbon, Inhumans, The Young Pope, Agent Carter and Black Mirror, and others.

DNEG might have grown in size and the scale of work it outputs, but the common theme among its crew is the level of creativity afforded to them every day, even in the sometimes cutthroat world of visual effects.

“Supervising is just as enjoyable for me today as it was back then,” says Chiang, who most recently oversaw Pacific Rim Uprising. “The projects are bigger and so we have grown the company, and the result is that we can do more creative things because we have fantastic, talented crew that work hard and know what they are doing. The company has invested in a more flexible pipeline that links the whole company to maximize this creative process allowing everyone to contribute in creating great shots.”

Co-founders Matt Holben (left) and Alex Hope.

Creative Peaks

A look at some of DNEG’s key creative moments over the years.

Pitch Black (2000): The project that kicked it all off and showcased DNEG’s early plans to work on high quality VFX.

Enemy At the Gates (2001): A major compositing project that pushed for a photorealistic depiction of the epic battle for Stalingrad in the Second World War.

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004): The studio’s first entry into the Harry Potter franchise. One of the most elaborate sequences in the film was the Night Bus journey, a DNEG creation.

Batman Begins (2005): DNEG’s first collaboration with Christopher Nolan, and one in which it established a new color-management pipeline to meet the director’s expectations.

Children of Men (2006): Long takes with seamless visual effects are characteristic of this Alfonso Cuarón outing, especially DNEG’s work in helping to orchestrate the famous ‘oner’ inside the car.

Bourne films, United 93, Captain Phillips, Green Zone: These films, representing DNEG’s collaboration with director Paul Greengrass, often feature scenes with seamless visual effects that go unnoticed by audiences.

The Dark Knight (2008) and The Dark Knight Rises (2012): Solidifying DNEG’s strong association with Nolan, these two films saw the studio come on board more as a creative partner.

Inception (2010): The VFX Oscar-winning film featured a diverse set of challenges for DNEG, from flipping Paris buildings, major wire removals for floating actors, and crumbling building façades for the limbo world.

John Carter (2012): A major leap forward in DNEG’s animation pipeline, involving on-set performance capture and delivering believable animated performances.

Interstellar (2014): DNEG collaborated with Professor Kip Thorne of Caltech on research and development into the visualization of blackholes for Interstellar, taking the idea of physically plausible visual effects to new levels, and earning a VFX Oscar.

Ex Machina (2015): Another Oscar winner for visual effects, Ex Machina was a much lower budgeted film, but still benefited greatly from DNEG’s approach to storytelling.

Blade Runner 2049 (2017): The studio delivered grand views of a future Los Angeles, as well as intricately orchestrated scenes of the holographic assistant Joi in one of the most hotly anticipated VFX films of last year.

FROM LEFT TO RIGHT: Visual Effects Supervisor Andrew Whitehurst: “One of my very fondest memories, and something which is unquestionably a perk of the job, was sitting down and sketching with Guillermo del Toro on Hellboy II. I was helping to create the Stone Giant and Guillermo had precise ideas about how he wanted the dust and debris to move. so we sat down and drew it together in my sketchpad. Moments when you get to directly create with someone of that caliber are to be treasured. And yes, I still have the drawings.”
Visual Effects Supervisor Charlie Noble: “From aerial work in the highlands of Scotland to the poorest back streets of Rabat, Morocco. From US Navy warships in San Diego and Virginia to U2 spy planes in Sacramento. From Berlin to Moscow, Madrid, Tangiers, New Orleans, New York, Boston, Budapest, Sofia, Murcia, Malta and Las Vegas, I’ve seen more hotel rooms than my family would have liked, but have also seen some amazing places. I am so grateful that my work at DNEG has led me to these places and to some of the wonderful people that I’ve met along the way.”
Visual Effects Supervisor John Moffatt: “The first show I worked on was Pitch Black. I earned the credit of ‘Digital Weasel’, and have many fond memories of being in late night reviews with Peter Chiang and Matt Plummer. I love creating amazing images with lovely people. That’s what we do at DNEG.”
Visual Effects Supervisor Pete Bebb: “One of my stand-out experiences at DNEG was when I was working in studio and I was on a night shift filming out Pitch Black. While trying to load a 1,000 ft. mag in a tiny space in the dark room I cut my finger on the film – like a paper cut but worse – and bled over the first few hundred feet of the roll. So I quite literally bled for that film. Hopefully you don’t notice it on the playback!”
Global Head of Animation Robyn Luckham: “My stand-out moments at DNEG have always been with the crew. Watching people start from scratch and grow. The bond we create as animators makes the work stronger and makes my job a lot easier. On In the Heart of the Sea we all became ‘Masters of Whales’. I would call my team my ‘shipmates’ and spent the whole show speaking like a pirate. I even received a ‘captain’s hat’ from the crew are amazing experiences and a huge part of that is the crew we get to work with.”

A Formidable Team

Perhaps one of DNEG’s most successful collaborations has been with director Christopher Nolan. Starting with Batman Begins and then continuing with the Dark Knight films, Inception, Interstellar and Dunkirk, DNEG has been the director’s go-to VFX house, even though he is often known for eschewing digital effects. The reality is that DNEG’s team members form just part of the many effects contributors, from special effects to practical effects and miniatures, on Nolan’s films.

“Chris has the sharpest eye of any filmmaker I have ever met,” says DNEG Visual Effects Supervisor Paul Franklin, a frequent Nolan collaborator. “The level of scrutiny he brings to bear on the work is absolutely punishing, and he makes it his business to learn as much as he can about your job, so you have to bring your A-game all the time. Chris is famous for putting as much reality on film as he possibly can. If he can get it in camera then he will, but this also means that when he looks to the VFX team to create images for the movie he expects them to be held to the same standard; it has to look real, no matter what it is.”

Franklin even teamed with Batman Begins overall VFX Supervisor Janek Sirrs to show Nolan digital versions of buildings and locations side-by-side with the real thing – on film – to help convince the director of the merits of VFX. “I think this helped to reassure Chris that we understood what he was looking for in the original photography and we went from there.”

Adds Franklin: “Perhaps the most important thing I learned from my work on Chris’s films is that you should never do something for its own sake, regardless of what it is: just because you have a Steadicam on the truck doesn’t mean you have to use it if the shot works just as well on regular sticks. The same goes for VFX – just because you can do something spectacular in the computer doesn’t automatically earn it a place in the movie.”

A scene from The Dark Knight. Although the film was a major blockbuster release, DNEG generally approached the visual effects as if they were largely invisible effects shots. (Image copyright © 2008 Warner Bros. Pictures. All rights reserved.)

Interstellar saw Nolan rely heavily on full-sized sets, miniatures from New Deal Studios, and computer simulations and visual effects by DNEG. In particular, the studio participated in the publication of new scientific papers involving the visualization of black holes. (Image copyright © 2014 Warner Bros. Pictures and Paramount Pictures Corp. All rights reserved.)

Paul Franklin (front) and fellow DNEG members on location during the production of The Dark Knight. (Image copyright © 2008 Warner Bros. Pictures. All rights reserved.)

Nolan’s latest film, Dunkirk, with visual effects supervised by Andrew Jackson, makes wide use of live-action, large-scale effects, miniatures, CG and seamless compositing from DNEG. (Image copyright © 2017 Warner Bros. Pictures. All rights reserved.)

Read about Double Negative’s “invisible effects” work on Baby Driver here!

Share this post with

Get the Latest VFX News

Receive notifications when WEB EXCLUSIVE or VFX WEEKLY content is posted on VFX Voice

Name *

Email *

Interested groups *
Web Exclusives
VFX Weekly

Most Popular Stories

The Miniature Models of <strong>BLADE RUNNER</strong>
02 October 2017
Company Profile
The Miniature Models of BLADE RUNNER
In 1982, Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner set a distinctive tone for the look and feel of many sci-fi future film noirs to come, taking advantage of stylized production design, art direction and visual effects work.
THE PEARL: THE SUPER ALIEN MODELS OF<strong> VALERIAN</strong>
02 August 2017
Company Profile
THE PEARL: THE SUPER ALIEN MODELS OF VALERIAN
Among the many creatures and aliens showcased in Luc Besson’s Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets are members of the Pearl, a beautiful...
Converting a Classic: How Stereo D Gave <strong>TERMINATOR 2: JUDGMENT DAY</strong> a 3D Makeover
24 August 2017
Company Profile
Converting a Classic: How Stereo D Gave TERMINATOR 2: JUDGMENT DAY a 3D Makeover
James Cameron loves stereo. He took full advantage of shooting in native 3D on Avatar, and has made his thoughts clear in recent times about the importance of shooting natively in stereo when possible...
2018 – Year of the Rapidly Expanding <b>VFX Moviemaking Vocabulary</b>
03 April 2018
Company Profile
2018 – Year of the Rapidly Expanding VFX Moviemaking Vocabulary
Industry leaders discuss trends and issues.
<b>AVATAR: FLIGHT OF PASSAGE</b>: A Cinematic, Multi-Sensory 3D Experience that Soars
24 June 2018
Company Profile
AVATAR: FLIGHT OF PASSAGE: A Cinematic, Multi-Sensory 3D Experience that Soars
How the sci-fi fantasy gem became a 3D thrill ride.